Sunday, 11 November 2007

Science vs Religion

I just read this in one of my new books that I got:

The idea that science and religion are in perpetual conflict is no longer taken seriously by any major historian of science, despite its popularity in the late nineteenth century. One of the last remaining bastions of atheism survives only at the popular level-namely, the myth that an atheistic, fact-based science is permanently at war with a faith-based religion. Not only is this caricature clearly untrue in the present day, but historical scholarship has now determined it to be misleading and inaccurate in the past. Yet the myth still lives on in popular atheist writings, undisturbed by the findings of scholars. At least in the minds of some atheist propagandists, science is the supreme champion of atheism. - Alister McGarth, The Twilight of Atheism (page 87)

I've understood science to be looking into how things work and then doing things with those discoveries.

Update: I've just found this link that argues against the chapter that I just quoted above. The author Dan J. Bye says they were: "Infuriated by McGrath’s distortions of atheism and its history, and by the generally dreadful quality of the scholarship on display in Twilight of atheism"

(Possibly) Related Posts:

  • Social ConstructThe idea that religion is a social construct has been around for awhile. Feuerbach, Marx and Freud I think promoted the idea. Today we have Harris, Dawkins, and Hitchens saying the same type of things. But what is there to sa… Read More
  • Reasons for God at GoogleEarlier this year Tim Keller talked to 150-200 Google employees about his book The Reason for God. Tim talks about how there is always an intellectual, personal and culture reason for believing or not believing in God. The Ch… Read More
  • There is a GodThat is the title of Antony Flew's new book.In 2001 after some Internet rumours Antony Flew was saying:I remain still what I have been now for over fifty years, a negative atheist. By this I mean that I construe the initial l… Read More
  • Religions are not great G. K. Chesterton wrote in Orthodoxy that it was not the arguments form Christians that convinced him of Christianity, but it was the arguments from atheists that made him convert. In the last chapter of that … Read More
  • Which God & what about Jesus?I have just started reading God is not Great by the late Christopher Hitchens (we'll see if I finished it and write a review of it). The second chapter in this book opens with: Imagine that you can perform a feat o… Read More

0 comments:

Post a Comment